1. Moisturizer, or, in my case, face oil: I use L'oreal Age Perfect Glow Renewal. Four drops on a clean face looks glow-y, not greasy, and sets the canvas for the rest of your face. I love the smell, too. It's kind of a fresh hippie calming sort of experience, like a little moment of clarity.
So, basically, curl, hold for like twenty seconds, coat of mascara and then curl again. And, if you're feeling adventurous, use a bit of liner under the lower lash line. I'm really shitty at eyeliner, so I just do a terrible job and everyone thinks I'm making a statement. Because that's how I'd do it if I had a statement to make, with eyeliner. Grab whatever, preferably a not-black color if you really want to stay "natural." I like Rimmel Soft Kohl Kajal eye liner in Sable Brown.
5. Mouth. Line and fill in your lips with Wet and Wild lipliner in Brandywine 666. Cover in Cherry Chapstick. Done. You're makeup free. You woke up like this.
The moral of this and every story is: do whatever the hell you want. But, be warned- if you tell someone you like the no-makeup look, one morning in the not too distant future they may be standing next to you in line at Market Basket in pajama pants and flip flops, hair back in a Scrunchie, with an industrial sized keg of Cheez Ballz under one arm. Looking beautiful, of course.